Denman Island: the bylaw audit

18 findings: 18 in proposals in the reviewed record. Read on 2026-09-20. Every quotation is a link to the words themselves.

Public-record check · 1 November 2026

Housing bylaws: no approval item on October 28 agenda

The October 28 Executive Committee agenda lists no bylaws for approval. The adopted October 14 minutes record approval of Saturna 146/147 and Salt Spring 553, with no Denman 260/264 decision. We have not verified a later Executive decision, ministerial approval or local adoption for Denman’s housing bylaws. An agenda’s silence does not establish whether the Secretary received a referral or started a statutory approval period. The September 15 local decision minutes were not found in the recent document listings checked.

Executive Committee agenda, October 28, page 1

Adopted October 14 Executive Committee minutes

September 15 housing-bylaw hearing notice

The incoming Trust Council

The Trust’s October 22 release confirms the elected or acclaimed trustees for the twelve local trust areas. Bowen’s municipal appointments remain pending until November 9. Trustees are scheduled to be sworn in on November 12, with inaugural Council meetings on November 13 and 14. The current term and the incoming term are distinct.

Trustee confirmation release, October 22

Ferry funding: the federal response

In an October 27 letter to the Trust, the federal Transport Minister describes the existing coastal ferry subsidy agreement. The letter puts the 2026–27 grant to British Columbia at approximately $38.6 million and says the Province determines which ferry services receive assistance. It directs questions about fares and service costs to the Province. This is a response about existing arrangements, rather than an announcement of a new local ferry service or fare reduction.

Federal Transport Minister’s response, October 27, pages 1–2

Other local votes · checked 21 October

The CVRD reports Daniel Arbour acclaimed as Electoral Area A director and Chelsea McCannel-Keene acclaimed as School District 71 Trustee Electoral Area 4 (Area A) trustee. Its official animal-control referendum count is 853 yes and 348 no. The question sought assent to Bylaw 915, which would add animal-control services to the Denman and Hornby bylaw-enforcement service. Voter assent is a separate step from the board adopting the bylaw.

Comox Valley Regional District, official election and referendum results

This is a dated status check, not a full re-audit of every bylaw.

Bylaw 264 would permit some additional secondary housing. We support housing people can actually build and occupy, and ask that the missing Rural Residential limit, Agriculture dwelling conflict and water-rule references be resolved. The publicly available text does not show all third-reading amendments.

The bylaws, and where each one stands

  • PROPOSED Denman Island Land Use Bylaw No. 264, 2026 (adoption not recorded here). Read a third time on 15 September 2026. The October 2 Ministry reply says OCP Bylaw 260 had not been referred for ministerial approval. Neither bylaw was before the Executive Committee on 9 September 2026 (its minutes record no bylaws for approval) or on its 23 September agenda, which lists only Galiano, Hornby and South Pender bylaws. The draft minutes of 23 September record decisions on those three islands' bylaws and none on Denman's. The agenda for the Executive Committee's 14 October 2026 meeting is posted (https://islandstrust.bc.ca/document/executive-committee-regular-meeting-agenda-78/#page=2); we read it on 12 October 2026. Its bylaws for approval are Saturna 146 and 147 and Salt Spring 553. Neither Denman bylaw is on it. The Trust's calendar shows the committee's next meeting after that on 28 October 2026. The date and receipt of any Executive Committee referral of 260 or Land Use Bylaw 264 have not been verified. Under Islands Trust Act s. 22, the one-month Executive Committee clock starts when its Secretary receives a bylaw, not at third reading.
  • Denman Island Land Use Bylaw No. 186 (in force). Proposed Bylaw 264 would repeal it and all of its amendments.

Correspondence Tony Aly reported sending

Tony confirmed sending the following letter on 3 October 2026. The text shown is the version we supplied for sending, with URLs written out for plain-text email. We have not independently verified the exact transmitted copy or received a response to this letter.

Denman Bylaw 264 – publish the third-reading text and correct operative housing rules

Reported sent:
To: execadmin@islandstrust.bc.ca
Cc: northinfo@islandstrust.bc.ca

Read the prepared letter
Dear Denman Island Local Trust Committee and Executive Committee,

I am writing about proposed Land Use Bylaw 264. Please send me the exact text as amended and read a third time on September 15, and confirm its present approval stage. The public cannot check a bylaw against amendments that have not been published.

Our line-by-line audit (https://abolishislandstrust.org/bylaw-audit/denman) identifies several substantive issues in the publicly available text. The Rural Residential zone does not specify the number of secondary dwellings allowed on lots of at least 4 hectares. The Agriculture zone retains one principal dwelling per 15 hectares while its next provision appears to cap every lot at one dwelling. Multiple water and subdivision conditions refer to sections that concern other subjects or do not exist. A secondary suite is defined as a secondary dwelling unit while some zone rules count the two separately. These are rules owners and applicants need to apply, not cosmetic typos.

I support additional homes that are actually permitted and buildable. Please publish the final reading text, identify whether the operative provisions and cross-references were corrected before approval, and explain how existing applications and permissions are treated when Bylaw 186 is repealed. Please identify each correction against the audit, including any that has already been made. If the Executive Committee has already decided, please provide its resolution and the available corrective route. This is a records and Executive Committee request, not a new Local Trust Committee hearing submission.

Sincerely,
Tony Aly

A letter you can send

Both bylaws received third reading on September 15. The Ministry confirmed October 2 that OCP Bylaw 260 had not been referred for ministerial approval. Neither bylaw was on the Executive Committee's 9 or 23 September agenda, and neither is on its agenda for 14 October 2026, which we read on 12 October. The Trust's calendar shows the next meeting after that on 28 October 2026. The date the Secretary received either bylaw has not been verified. Section 22 runs from the Secretary receiving a bylaw, so the third-reading date alone does not start the one-month clock.

To: the Executive Committee of the Islands Trust
Subject: Denman Bylaws 260 and 264 – confirm referral and correct operative rules

To the Executive Committee of the Islands Trust,

I am writing about Denman Bylaws 260 and 264, which received third reading on September 15. Please confirm whether and when each was referred to the Executive Committee and provide the current text and decisions. [Say here whether you own, rent or live on Denman Island, and where.]

These are the points that concern me:

- On Rural Residential lots of 4.0 hectares or more, the bylaw never says how many secondary dwelling units are allowed.
- The Agriculture zone keeps the rule of one principal dwelling per 15.0 hectares, and the next subsection caps every lot at one dwelling unit.
- Four zones send proof of water to section 8.7(1), which is the rule about lot width and depth.
- The Agriculture zone sends proof of water to section 2.19, and Part 2 stops at section 2.10.
- Bylaw 186 and all its amendments are repealed, and the new bylaw has no transition section.
- The committee amended Bylaw 264 at third reading, and the amended text has not been published while the approval clock runs.

The words of the bylaw behind each point are quoted, with a link to the place they can be read, at https://abolishislandstrust.org/bylaw-audit/denman

If Executive Committee approval remains pending, please consider returning the affected bylaw under section 22(1)(b)(ii) with directions to correct the documented operative errors. If a decision has been made, please provide it and identify the corrective route. Please do not infer a one-month deadline from third reading alone.

Yours respectfully,
[Your name]
[Your address on Denman Island, or your interest in the trust area]

Open an email to execadmin@islandstrust.bc.ca

Change anything you do not agree with, and say who you are and where you live or own land. A few sentences in your own words are worth more than ours.

The plain-words version, to print and pass on

One page, written for a neighbour, not a planner: what Bylaws 260 and 264 change, the map of the 934 lots, and the answer to the “doesn’t every R2 lot get a second house now?” question. Print the PDF (letter size, one page) · share the image (one tall image for a phone).

Findings in proposed texts

The findings concern the texts cited here. Confirm current adoption status before acting.

Something left out · in a proposal in the reviewed record

On Rural Residential lots of 4.0 hectares or more, the bylaw never says how many secondary dwelling units are allowed.

Section 5.2(4) sets the number for lots under 4.0 hectares and section 5.2(3) limits principal dwellings only. The Agriculture and Forestry zones each state a limit. Rural Residential, which is 259 of the 894 lots we map, does not.

Something left out · in a proposal in the reviewed record

Bylaw 186 and all its amendments are repealed, and the new bylaw has no transition section.

Nothing tells an owner with an application or a permit under Bylaw 186 which rules apply on the day Bylaw 264 is adopted. Section 2.9 is headed Repeal and Replacement but deals only with references to other Acts and renamed agencies.

Two rules that cannot both be obeyed · in a proposal in the reviewed record

The definitions make a secondary suite a kind of secondary dwelling unit, and the zones count the two separately.

On the bylaw's own definition, the Agriculture zone's choice of one secondary suite or secondary dwelling unit is a choice between a thing and itself.

Two rules that cannot both be obeyed · in a proposal in the reviewed record

The Agriculture zone keeps the rule of one principal dwelling per 15.0 hectares, and the next subsection caps every lot at one dwelling unit.

A rule of one home per 15.0 hectares can never do anything under a flat cap of one. On a 40.5 hectare lot outside the Agricultural Land Reserve, two principal homes become one.

A reference to something that does not exist · in a proposal in the reviewed record

The Agriculture zone sends proof of water to section 2.19, and Part 2 stops at section 2.10.

In Bylaw 186 the water rules are in section 2.8. The 17 April 2026 draft changed that number to 2.19 in all five zones, in tracked changes. Four were later changed again to 8.7(1). The Agriculture zone was missed.

A reference to something that does not exist · in a proposal in the reviewed record

Sections 8.5(1) and 8.5(2) rely on sections 8.12(2) and 8.12(3), and section 8.12 has one subsection.

Both are exceptions to the rule against creating non-conforming lots. The provisions they point at do not exist, so nobody can tell what the exception is.

A reference to something that does not exist · in a proposal in the reviewed record

The water supply standards are said to be in sections 8.7(2) to 8.7(4). Section 8.7 has two subsections, and the second is about highway frontage.

Sections 8.8(1) and 8.9(4)(b) both point there. The standards they mean are in section 8.8 itself, at 8.8(2) to 8.8(4). In 8.8(1) the words of this section also contradict the number.

A reference to something that does not exist · in a proposal in the reviewed record

The temporary use permit rules list a Resource zone. Bylaw 264 has no Resource zone.

Section 4.1(1) lists every zone in the bylaw. Resource is not among them. It was a zone in Bylaw 186.

A reference to something that does not exist · in a proposal in the reviewed record

A site-specific rule allows a restaurant in addition to the uses in Table 1. Bylaw 264 has no Table 1.

Bylaw 186 sets out permitted uses in tables. Bylaw 264 replaced the tables with lists and repeals Bylaw 186, but rule A(2)(a) still relies on the table.

A reference that lands on the wrong subject · in a proposal in the reviewed record

Four zones send proof of water to section 8.7(1), which is the rule about lot width and depth.

Sections 5.1(13), 5.2(14), 5.3(12) and 5.6(17) are conditions a landowner has to meet before building. Each applies the water rules in section 8.7(1). Section 8.7 is Lot Configuration Regulations. The water rules are sections 8.8 to 8.11.

A reference that lands on the wrong subject · in a proposal in the reviewed record

A second principal dwelling needs proof of water according to section 8.7, which is about lot shape.

Section 3.5(1) calls section 8.7 proof of water for a subdivision. It is not.

A reference that lands on the wrong subject · in a proposal in the reviewed record

Two site-specific farm rules make subdivision subject to section 2.8, which is Enforcement of Siting Regulations.

The words were copied from Bylaw 186, where section 2.8 was the subdivision rules. Those rules are now Part 8 and the references were not updated.

A reference that lands on the wrong subject · in a proposal in the reviewed record

The temporary use permit rules make guest rooms subject to section 2.4, which is Violation.

In Bylaw 186 section 2.4 was the home occupation rules. In Bylaw 264 those are section 3.17.

A reference that lands on the wrong subject · in a proposal in the reviewed record

The same permit area makes screening subject to section 2.7, which is Owner's Cost.

In Bylaw 186 section 2.7 was the screening rules. In Bylaw 264 those are section 3.16.

A leftover from an older bylaw or a repealed law · in a proposal in the reviewed record

Three water provisions ask for something complying with Regulation of Section 2.6, which does not parse.

Bylaw 186 read Regulation 4 of Section 1.2. The numbers were changed and the words around them were left behind.

What the Trust has published · in a proposal in the reviewed record

The committee amended Bylaw 264 at third reading, and the amended text has not been published while the approval clock runs.

Staff describe the amendments as inserting missing parcel identifiers, with no change to zone boundaries, regulations or permitted uses. That is their account of a document nobody outside the Trust has seen.

Numbering and proofreading · in a proposal in the reviewed record

The numbering has four slips: a (20) between (12) and (13), a section whose only subsection is (3), no section 5.13, and a provision printed 20) with no opening bracket.

None of these changes what the bylaw means. Together they show that nobody read the text from beginning to end before third reading.

Numbering and proofreading · in a proposal in the reviewed record

The bylaw's own title page spells the committee COMMITEE and dates the bylaw 2022. Section 1 on the same page cites it as 2026.

The Executive Committee approves a bylaw by its citation, and the page that gives the citation disagrees with itself.