One field. Two rule books.
Let farmers farm.
People who grow food deserve clear rules. Cut needless hurdles and let them get on with the work.
The demand
Keep the farm land protected. Keep the B.C. farm rules. Then let a normal elected local government make the zoning call. And answer for it.
The full case. Sources and details.
We have no proof that the Agricultural Land Commission and the Islands Trust are at war. They are two bodies. They make rules for the same land. When their rules clash, the B.C. law wins. The local rule stops working, but only as far as the clash goes.
What we found
The Commission guards farm land across B.C. The Trust sets local zoning. That means what you may build and do on your land. The Trust does that within the powers it has. Both can cover the same field. Where the two rules clash, the B.C. law comes first.
- There is a B.C. law called the Agricultural Land Commission Act. It gives the Commission one job for the whole province. Keep farm land as farm land.
- Local zoning can set rules for named farm uses. But it must stay inside the limits B.C. sets. It cannot ban a use that the B.C. rules protect.
- Shutting the Trust down would not touch the Commission. It would move the local land call to a town council or a regional district.
Sources you can check
- Agricultural Land Commission Act, SBC 2002, c. 36 — ss. 6 and 46; verified 2026-08-24.
- Agricultural Land Reserve Use Regulation, BC Reg. 30/2019 — ss. 4–5; verified 2026-08-24.
Read the detailed ALC record · How the Trust actually functions
The Trust's job is to keep the islands. Not to keep us on them.
The law that made the Islands Trust gives it one job: preserve and protect the islands. It does not tell the Trust to house anyone. The rules follow the job, and the islands keep getting older.
This page is step 3 of four: The rules. The bylaws follow the rule book. On nine islands we checked every home lot. On about two in three, the rules allow no second, smaller home.
Being fair: These are rules on paper, not homes refused. The count says nothing about who applied, who was turned down, or who was kept out. Four islands are missing from it because their rules depend on maps we cannot yet match to lots, and we name them rather than guess.