All posts

They used to write the date down. They stopped, and nobody noticed.

The Islands Trust has one month to say yes or no to a bylaw. That is the law. The month starts on the day their Secretary in Victoria receives it.

So that one date decides everything. Miss the month and the bylaw passes anyway. The law says so.

They print that date on a form. Every bylaw from every island goes to Victoria on the same cover sheet, and it has four boxes.

The form every island fills in

An Islands Trust form headed Local Trust Committee Bylaws, Submission for Executive committee Approval. The date of the resolution referring the bylaw reads 25-Aug-2026 and three checkboxes are ticked. Below, under the heading Recieved by Islands Trust Secretary, the signature line, the date line, the line for the deadline for the Executive Committee decision and the line for the date the bylaw will appear on the agenda are all empty.
The form, as the Islands Trust prints it. Galiano Bylaw 300, in the Executive Committee agenda package of 23 September 2026, page 31. The island's date is filled in. The Secretary's date, the deadline and the agenda date are blank. “Recieved” is their spelling. We read 87 of these sheets, covering 83 bylaws. See it full size
  • Filled in — The island's date. 25-Aug-2026.
  • Left blank — Who signed, and when.
  • Left blank — The day to decide by.
  • Left blank — The day it is heard.

Here is the part we did not expect. **They used to fill it in.**

On 19 July 2017 the Secretary wrote in all three dates and signed the form by hand. Ten bylaws that day, from five islands — Denman’s Bylaw 222 among them. On 1 November 2017 she did it again for Denman’s Bylaw 227: received 26 October, deadline 27 November, on the agenda 1 November. The deadline is worked out correctly, to the day.

So the box is not decoration. It can be filled in. Somebody once did it properly.

The same form, other islands, the same three blank lines.

Hornby Island · Bylaw 176

The same Islands Trust submission form, for Hornby Island Bylaw 176. The date of the resolution referring the bylaw reads 01-Sep-2026. Under the heading Recieved by Islands Trust Secretary the signature line, the date line, the deadline line and the agenda line are all empty.
Hornby Island Bylaw 176, an Official Community Plan bylaw referred on 01-Sep-2026. Executive Committee agenda package of 23 September 2026, page 81. See it full size

Our count of their forms:

  • The island's box, filled in: 86 of 87
  • Victoria's three boxes, filled in: 0 of 87

Salt Spring Island · Bylaw 553

The same Islands Trust submission form, for Salt Spring Island Bylaw 553. The date of the resolution referring the bylaw reads 24-Sep-2026. Under the heading Recieved by Islands Trust Secretary the signature line, the date line, the deadline line and the agenda line are all empty.
Salt Spring Island Bylaw 553, an Official Community Plan bylaw referred on 24-Sep-2026. Executive Committee agenda package of 14 October 2026, page 61. See it full size

Since then: **233 cover sheets published, and not one of them completed.**

We read 87 of those sheets closely — covering 83 bylaws decided since January 2024. The island fills in its own box 86 times out of 87. Victoria’s three boxes — the day they got it, the deadline, the day it goes on the agenda — are blank every single time.

Denman, 2009

The same Islands Trust submission form, dated January 2009, for Denman Island Land Use Bylaw No. 186. The date of the referring resolution reads January 2, 2009 and three attachment boxes are ticked by hand. The signature line, the date received, the deadline and the agenda date are all empty.
Seventeen years earlier, the same blank. Denman Island Land Use Bylaw No. 186, submitted 28 January 2009 — the bylaw the Trust is enforcing on this island today. Referred 2 January, approved 3 February. Whether the Committee was inside its month depends on the date in the empty box. See it full size

We did not just read the words. A printed form can hide handwriting that text searching cannot see, so we rendered all 87 pages as pictures and counted the ink in each box. The 2017 forms light up. The other 87 are empty, all four boxes, every one.

From today's agenda

A line from an Executive Committee agenda reading: BYLAWS FOR APPROVAL CONSIDERATION - None.
The Executive Committee agenda for 18 November 2026. The same line appears on 28 October and 14 November. See it full size

From a staff memorandum

A line from a staff memorandum reading: Staff intend to forward the bylaws for consideration at the Executive Committee's January 20, 2027 meeting.
Written on Monday, two months after the vote. Staff memorandum for the Denman Local Trust Committee meeting of 16 November 2026, page 21. See it full size

From their own task list

A row from the Denman Local Trust Committee follow-up action report reading FUAL-2026-105, Legislative Process for Bylaw Nos. 260 and 264, with no person assigned and nought per cent complete.
Their own task list, printed 6 November 2026. Sending our bylaws to Victoria: unassigned, nought per cent. Denman Local Trust Committee agenda package of 16 November 2026, page 17. See it full size

Their own rules say someone writes that date down. Their Governance Committee read those words again on 8 October this year: the Secretary records the date each bylaw is received and puts a tracking sheet in the agenda package. The sheet is in the package. The boxes on it are empty.

And the same office does record receipt when it matters to them. On another form in the very same meeting papers, a stamp reads: “RECEIVED BY THE ISLANDS TRUST SECRETARY THIS 3RD DAY OF OCTOBER 2025”.

Now Denman. Our housing bylaws passed on 15 September. The committee voted the same day to send them to Victoria. That was 64 days ago. Five Executive Committee meetings have come and gone. The last three agendas say “Bylaws for approval consideration — None.” A staff memo written on Monday says staff “intend to forward” them in January.

Hornby passed the same kind of pair two weeks before us. Hornby was done in 22 days.

We are not saying anyone broke the law. We cannot — because the date that would settle it is the one date nobody writes down any more. The rules are tight where you cannot see, and wide open where you can.

Denman Island deserves good governance.

One question would end this. On what day did the Secretary receive Denman Bylaws 260 and 264?

Where this comes from

  • Executive Committee bylaw submission cover sheets, 87 forms, EC agenda packages Jan 2024 - Nov 2026
  • Islands Trust, Executive Committee Roles & Responsibilities, in the Governance Committee agenda of 8 October 2026
  • Islands Trust Act, R.S.B.C. 1996, c. 239, ss. 22(1)(c), 22(2), 27(1)
  • Denman LTC adopted minutes of 15 September 2026, DE-2026-082 and DE-2026-083
  • Denman LTC follow-up action report printed 6 November 2026, FUAL-2026-105
  • Staff memorandum, Denman LTC Orientation, 16 November 2026 agenda package, item 15.1, p.21
  • Executive Committee agendas of 28 October, 14 November and 18 November 2026, item 7
  • Executive Committee agenda packages of 19 July 2017 and 1 November 2017, the completed cover sheets (Denman Bylaws 222 and 227 among them)
  • docs/research/ec-deadline-20261118/VERIFY-form-sweep.md — 87 sheets re-derived twice, and all 87 pages pixel-tested for handwriting

More posts

Sign the petition