All posts

Every hearing since 2011 produced a record. This one has not.

When the Islands Trust holds a public hearing, what people said is written down. Not in the meeting minutes — those just say the meeting stopped and started again. The hearing itself goes into its own document, called a Public Hearing Record. Then that record is handed to the committee at a later meeting, in public.

Denman has done this for every hearing we can find, going back to 2011.

Take February this year. Two hearings on 17 February. Both records went to the committee on 17 March, as items 6.3 and 6.4. Exactly how it should work.

The same committee, eight months apart

17 March 2026 — how it is meant to work

The minutes section of a Denman Local Trust Committee agenda. Item 6.3 reads: Local Trust Committee Public Hearing Record for Bylaw Nos. 255, 254 and 250 dated February 17, 2026 - for receipt, pages 16 to 19. Item 6.4 reads: Local Trust Committee Public Hearing Record for Bylaw Nos. 256 and 257 dated February 17, 2026 - for receipt, pages 20 to 22.
Two hearings were held on 17 February. Four weeks later both records came to the committee, in public, with page numbers. Denman Local Trust Committee agenda of 17 March 2026, page 1. See it full size

Now the hearing on our housing bylaws, 15 September.

No record has been published. And the committee met on 16 November, nine weeks later, and did not receive one either. Look at the index of that meeting. Item 10 reads: “PUBLIC HEARING - none.”

16 November 2026 — nine weeks after our hearing

The index of a Denman Local Trust Committee agenda. The top line is the end of item 7.1.1, reading September 15, 2026 - for Information, page 4. Below it items 7.2, 7.3, 8 and 9, and then item 10, which reads: PUBLIC HEARING - none.
The same meeting took the adopted minutes of 15 September — the line at the top — and no record of the hearing itself. Item 10: none. Denman Local Trust Committee agenda of 16 November 2026, page 2. See it full size

We are careful here. The law says that record must be prepared and kept. We cannot see inside their filing cabinet, so we do not say it was never made. We say this: **it has not been published, and it has not been put in front of the committee.**

Two things turn on it, and neither is small.

First, who may vote. The Local Government Act says a member who missed the hearing can only vote to adopt the bylaw if they have been given a report of it. Denman staff relied on exactly that rule in 2023. No record, no report.

Second, the Minister. Bylaw 260 changes our Official Community Plan, so it goes to the Minister as well. The Ministry’s own checklist for that — handed to this committee in its 24 August meeting papers — lists what must be sent. One line says: public hearing record, minutes, binder.

What the Province asks for

A checklist under the heading Public Engagement. It requires public engagement materials including statutory requirements: information demonstrating how the Trust met the statutory requirements for notice of a public hearing per s.466 of the Local Government Act and s.94 of the Community Charter; and, on its own line, public hearing record slash minutes slash binder.
The Ministry’s own checklist for an Official Community Plan bylaw, handed to this committee in its 24 August 2026 meeting papers. Fourth line down: public hearing record/minutes/binder. Bylaw 260 is an Official Community Plan bylaw. See it full size

So the bylaws may be missing a document the Minister asks for, and nobody has said so out loud.

Denman Island deserves good governance.

Where is the Public Hearing Record for 15 September 2026?

Where this comes from

  • Denman LTC regular meeting agenda of 16 November 2026, index item 10, “PUBLIC HEARING - none”
  • Denman LTC regular meeting agenda of 17 March 2026, items 6.3 and 6.4 (the 17 February 2026 hearing records)
  • Local Government Act s. 465(5) (the record is prepared and maintained) and s. 470(2)-(3) (a member absent from the hearing)
  • Ministry of Housing and Municipal Affairs OCP submission checklist, in the Denman LTC agenda package of 24 August 2026
  • docs/research/ec-deadline-20261118/VERIFY-hearing-and-report.md — every Denman hearing record back to 2011 checked, and the one claim we killed before publishing it

More posts

Sign the petition