The housing bylaw says one home per lot. Two rules later, it says three.
They were in too much of a hurry to wait three weeks. So let us read what they passed.
Bylaw 264 is the one meant to let people add a second small home or a suite.
In the Agriculture zone it says: “Only one (1) dwelling unit is permitted per lot, both inside and outside the Agricultural Land Reserve.”
A little further down the same zone, it permits “a maximum of one (1) secondary suite and one (1) secondary dwelling unit per lot”.
Now read their own dictionary. The bylaw defines a dwelling unit as “a building, or set of rooms in a building” used as a separate home. So a suite is a dwelling unit. And a detached secondary dwelling unit is defined as — their words — “a detached dwelling unit”.
So one rule allows three homes and another allows one. The same zone. The same bylaw. The same day.
The Forestry zone does the same thing. Those two zones cover most of this island.
It gets worse when you look at what it replaced. The old rule said “not applicable” for Agriculture, and allowed a suite and a second home on farm land. The new one puts a flat cap on, reaching into the Agricultural Land Reserve. And our Official Community Plan right now, in Policy 15, plainly expects three homes on a farm lot — so the new rule contradicts the plan as well as itself.
Then Bylaw 260 deletes Policies 14, 15 and 16, the only density policies the plan has for farm and resource land.
This is not the only one. Elsewhere the bylaw sends you to a section 2.19 that does not exist — Part 2 stops at 2.10. It lists the zones and calls them seventeen when it sets out sixteen. The committee spotted that property numbers had been left out of the zone tables and fixed it on the day; the fix named twelve zones and missed three.
This is what three weeks in harvest buys you.
Denman Island deserves good governance.
Where this comes from
- Denman Island Bylaw No. 264, Agriculture s. 5.5 and Forestry s. 5.6, with the definitions of “dwelling unit”, “secondary suite” and “detached secondary dwelling unit”
- Denman Island Land Use Bylaw No. 186, Table 3 lines 3, 8 and 9, as the provisions 264 replaces
- Denman Island Official Community Plan, Policy 15, and Bylaw No. 260 item 33 (deleting Policies 14 to 16)
- Denman LTC resolution DE-2026-078 (the site-specific zone list)
- docs/research/ec-deadline-20261118/VERIFY-bylaw-defects.md